Armenian findings provide insight into Lower to Middle Palaeolithic transition
The Middle Stone Age/Middle Palaeolithic saw a shift in emphasis from hand-axe (biface) manufacture to prepared-core methods. In the former, flakes detached from a stone core are regarded as waste products; in the latter, flakes detached from a pre-shaped stone core are the desired products. The shift to prepared-core industries probably came about as toolmakers began to recognise that debitage (waste flakes) could often be useful tools in their own right. Such methods are economical in their use of raw materials, because many flakes may be struck from the same core.
Prepared-core techniques include the Levallois method. It is named after the Parisian suburb of Levallois-Perret, where examples of prepared cores were found in the nineteenth century. The Levallois method involves at least five or six clearly separate stages, each of which requires careful preplanning. Flakes were first struck off around the periphery of a raw stone nodule; the scars from this process were then used as striking platforms (the point where a stone core is struck by a hammerstone) to remove flakes from one surface of the nodule. From the resulting core, one or more flakes could now be detached, the shape and size of which being predetermined by the core preparation. Flakes so produced were fashioned into as many as forty distinct tool types, each with its own specific cutting, scraping or piercing function. There was a much greater standardisation in the form of the tools made, indicating a clearer mental template and greater manipulative skill applied to their manufacture.
What has been unclear is whether this method was developed just once, and spread with populations, or whether it was independently invented on multiple occasions. In Africa, the Early to Middle Stone Age transition is characterised by the gradual replacement of bifaces by flakes, points, and blades produced through various prepared-core methods, principally the Levallois method. On the single-invention picture, such a gradual transition would not be seen elsewhere; rather there would be a discontinuity as human groups dumped their outmoded Acheulean hand-axes and adopted the new technology.
However, recent findings from the site of Nor Geghi 1, Armenia (NG1) suggest that this was not the case. A mixture of Acheulean and Levallois artefacts have been recovered, 316 in all, made from locally-available obsidian. The artefacts are around 300,000 years old and are the earliest examples of this technology to be found outside of Africa.
The findings support the hypothesis that Levallois technology arose gradually from Acheulean technology on multiple occasions and its presence in Africa and Eurasia represents technological convergence rather than a ‘technical breakthrough’ that spread from a single point of origin.
Reference:
1. Adler, D. et al., Early Levallois technology and the Lower to Middle Paleolithic transition in the Southern Caucasus. Science 345 (6204), 1609-1612 (2014).
Tuesday, 7 October 2014
Wednesday, 3 September 2014
Neanderthal rock engraving
Important
evidence for symbolic behaviour from Gorham’s Cave, Gibraltar
Archaeologists from the Gibraltar
Caves project have found a rock engraving at Gorham’s Cave on the eastern side
of Gibraltar. The deeply-etched cross-hatched pattern is carved into the dolomite
bedrock of the cave, and was wholly-covered by an undisturbed archaeological
level containing Mousterian artefacts. Thus its association with Neanderthals
is secure.
The engraving is at least 39,000
years old and although modern humans were in Europe by that time, they had not
yet reached the southern Iberian Peninsula. Furthermore, the Gibraltar rock
engraving predates the earliest Aurignacian cave art, suggesting that it was an
independent Neanderthal development.
Researchers carried out a number of
tests to demonstrate that the engraving was intentional. They used a variety of
tools and cutting actions on blocks of dolomite rock similar to the rock face
at Gorham's cave and found that results best matching the engraving were
achieved by using a pointed tool to create and enlarge a groove. Considerable
care and physical effort was required to produce similar markings. The
researchers also used the sharp tools to cut pork skin on a dolomite slab to
rule out the possibility that the pattern had been produced accidentally while
cutting meat or working animal hides.
The Gorham’s Cave rock engraving is
only the latest in a series of recent discoveries that clearly demonstrate that
the Neanderthals were not the dimwits of popular imagination. It is possibly
the strongest indication yet that they were capable of symbolic behaviour
References:
x
1. Rodríguez-Vidal, J. et
al., A rock engraving made by Neanderthals in Gibraltar. PNAS (Early
edition) (2014).
Link:
x
Tuesday, 2 September 2014
Neolithic boom-to-bust
Transition
to agriculture triggered demographic growth followed by collapse
Researchers have used two sets of
data from the period 6000 to 2000 BC to investigate the demographics of the
transition to agriculture in Europe: data from cemeteries, and radiocarbon
dates from 24 well-documented archaeological regions across Europe.
The juvenility index is the
proportion of a population aged between 5 and 19 years old: in an increasing
population, this is high; in a declining population it is low. Researchers obtained
data from 212 cemeteries, weighting results by settlement size. They then considered
the Summed Calibrated Radiocarbon Date Probability Distribution (SCDPD) of 8,032
radiocarbon dates, which can be used as a proxy for population density and
indicate whether populations are rising or falling at a given time.
Both sets of data gave similar
results. The transition from Mesolithic to Neolithic in each region was
accompanied by a sharp increase in the population, but after a period of stability
there was a decline. The cemetery data indicated a period of growth lasting for
about 720 years, a period of stability lasting for just under 1,000 years,
followed by a decline. The use of radiocarbon dates is less proven as a proxy,
but because far more data is available it should provide higher resolution
results. The radiocarbon dates indicated that the period of growth had lasted
for 420 years before a decline set in, lasting for 840 years for a complete
boom to bust cycle of 1,260 years. That the two sets of results are reasonably
consistent confirms SCDPD as a valid demographic proxy.
References:
x
1. Downey, S., Bocaege,
E., Kerig, T., Edinborough, K. & Shennan, S., Correlation with Juvenility
Index Supports Interpretation of the Summed Calibrated Radiocarbon Date
Probability Distribution (SCDPD) as a Valid Demographic Proxy. PLoS One 9
(8), e105730 (2014).
x
Link:
Friday, 29 August 2014
Prehistory of New World Arctic investigated in major new genetic study
Paleo-Eskimos
were independent of Inuit and Native American expansions
In the 1980s, the American linguist
Joseph Greenberg proposed that Native American languages could be classified
within three families: Eskimo-Aleut, Na Dene and Amerind. He further suggested
that each family corresponded to a separate migration into the New World from
Siberia and concluded, therefore, that the New World had been peopled by three
migrations. Greenberg’s views remained controversial for many years as most mitochondrial
and Y-chromosomal genetic studies indicated that there had been no more than
two migrations. In 2012, however, he was apparently vindicated when David Reich
and his colleagues presented a high resolution study of 52 Native American and 17
Siberian groups genotyped at 364,470 single nucleotide polymorphisms. The
results indicated that there had indeed been three migrations broadly
corresponding to the three language families: specifically (i) First Americans,
(ii) Eskimo-Aleuts and, (iii) Saqqaq and Na Dene speakers.
These results are built on by a
major new study conducted by an international team numbering over fifty
researchers led by geneticist Maanasa Raghavan from the University of
Copenhagen. The study focussed on mitochondrial and genome-wide sequences
obtained from ancient bone, hair and teeth samples of Arctic Siberia, Alaska,
Canada, and Greenland, and high-coverage genomes of two present-day Greenlandic
Inuit, two Siberian Nivkhs, one Aleutian Islander, and two Athabascan Native
Americans.
From this data, researchers hoped
to resolve issues regarding the complex archaeological record of the Early
Paleo-Eskimos (Pre-Dorset/Saqqaq), the Late Paleo-Eskimos (Early Dorset, Middle
Dorset, and Late Dorset), and the Thule cultures. They were able to show that
the Paleo-Eskimos reached the New World in a single migration from Siberia around
3000 BC and displayed genetic continuity for more 4,000 years. About 700 years
ago they were replaced by the Thule people, who were the ancestors of the
present day Inuit.
While supporting Reich et al overall, the results indicated
that the Saqqaq tradition and Na Dene speakers were not part of the same
migratory wave: accordingly the Paleo-Eskimos must have arrived in a separate
migration to the three waves identified by Reich et al, implying that the New World was populated by four migrations
in all.
References:
x
1. Reich, D. et al.,
Reconstructing Native American population history. Nature 488,
370–374 (2012).
2. Greenberg, J., Turner, C. &
Zegura, S., The Settlement of the Americas: A Comparison of the Linguistic,
Dental, and Genetic Evidence. Current Anthropology 27 (5),
477-497 (1986).
3. Raghavan, M. et al., The
genetic prehistory of the New World Arctic. Science 345 (620),
1020,1255832 (2014).
x
Thursday, 21 August 2014
Neanderthals coexisted with modern humans for up to 5,000 years
New radiocarbon
dates point to longer coexistence but earlier extinction
A new study published in the
journal Nature suggests that
Neanderthals persisted alongside modern humans in Europe for as long as 5,000
years after the arrival of the latter. A team lead by Tom Higham at Oxford
obtained 196 AMS radiocarbon dates from 40 sites across Europe, relying on improved
techniques to remove young carbon contamination. The results also indicate that
the Neanderthals were probably extinct no later than 41,000 to 39,000 years
ago.
Although it was once believed
that Neanderthals and modern humans had coexisted for up to 10,000 years, work
in the middle of the last decade suggested that the overlap was very brief. The new results represent a reversion to the
earlier position, albeit pushed further back in time since it is now believed
that modern humans first reached Europe about 46,000 years ago (Higham’s team suggest
the date was around 45,000 years ago).
The new dates may resolve long-running
controversy over the Châtelperronian culture, with is believed to be of
Neanderthal origin but incorporates elements associated with modern human
behaviour. The dates indicate that the Châtelperronian began around 45,000
years ago, suggesting that it was influenced by interaction with modern humans.
The Châtelperronian comes to an end at about the same time as the Mousterian,
about 41,000 to 39,000 years ago
.
The researchers were
unfortunately unable to obtain any dates for remains from Gorham’s Cave, Gibraltar,
where Neanderthal survival after 30,000 years ago has been claimed.
The lengthy overlap rules out
the in any case improbable hypothesis that modern humans hunted down and
exterminated the Neanderthals. It is more likely that a combination of increased
competition for limited resources and the Heinrich Event 4 climatic downturn
40,000 years ago was responsible.
References:
Higham, T. et al., The timing and spatiotemporal patterning of Neanderthal disappearance. Nature 512, 306-309 (2014).
Friday, 8 August 2014
Gibraltar Neanderthals ate roasted pigeons
Further evidence of Neanderthal sophistication at Gorham’s Cave
Gorham’s Cave, Gibraltar, was occupied by Neanderthals for thousands of years and was one of the last known sites of Neanderthal occupation before their final disappearance. Researchers have been working at the cave site for the past 25 years, and it has yielded a wealth of data about Neanderthal technology and patterns of subsistence.
In a survey published online in Nature Scientific Reports, researchers examined 1,724 Rock dove (common pigeon) bones from the cave, spanning the period from 67,000 to 28,000 years ago. All but the most recent part of this time period is associated with Mousterian technology, implying that the occupants of the cave at that time were Neanderthals. Modern human Upper Palaeolithic technology does not appear until near the end of the sequence.
Some of the bones were unevenly discoloured, consistent with roasting over a fire or glowing embers. Bones with less meat on them would have been more intensely affected by the heat, and would consequently undergo more discoloration than meatier bones. Some bones also displayed cut marks and/or tooth marks.
The exploitation of the pigeons was not sporadic: there is repeated evidence for the practice throughout the time that Neanderthals were resident in the cave. Furthermore, they could not have learned about it from modern humans as the earlier evidence substantially predates the arrival of modern humans in Europe.
That the Gorham’s Cave Neanderthals were able to regularly exploit this reliable and sustainable source of food is further evidence of their sophistication.
References:
1. Blasco, R. et al., The earliest pigeon fanciers. Nature Scientific Reports online (2014).
Link:
http://www.nature.com/srep/2014/140807/srep05971/full/srep05971.html
Gorham’s Cave, Gibraltar, was occupied by Neanderthals for thousands of years and was one of the last known sites of Neanderthal occupation before their final disappearance. Researchers have been working at the cave site for the past 25 years, and it has yielded a wealth of data about Neanderthal technology and patterns of subsistence.
In a survey published online in Nature Scientific Reports, researchers examined 1,724 Rock dove (common pigeon) bones from the cave, spanning the period from 67,000 to 28,000 years ago. All but the most recent part of this time period is associated with Mousterian technology, implying that the occupants of the cave at that time were Neanderthals. Modern human Upper Palaeolithic technology does not appear until near the end of the sequence.
Some of the bones were unevenly discoloured, consistent with roasting over a fire or glowing embers. Bones with less meat on them would have been more intensely affected by the heat, and would consequently undergo more discoloration than meatier bones. Some bones also displayed cut marks and/or tooth marks.
The exploitation of the pigeons was not sporadic: there is repeated evidence for the practice throughout the time that Neanderthals were resident in the cave. Furthermore, they could not have learned about it from modern humans as the earlier evidence substantially predates the arrival of modern humans in Europe.
That the Gorham’s Cave Neanderthals were able to regularly exploit this reliable and sustainable source of food is further evidence of their sophistication.
References:
1. Blasco, R. et al., The earliest pigeon fanciers. Nature Scientific Reports online (2014).
Link:
http://www.nature.com/srep/2014/140807/srep05971/full/srep05971.html
Thursday, 7 August 2014
Is Homo floresiensis a valid species?
New papers revive ‘hobbit’ controversy
The announcement in 2003 that dwarf hominins had been discovered at Liang Bua Cave on the Indonesian island of Flores was one of the major news stories of that year. The type specimen, LB1, a female inevitably dubbed ‘Flo’ had lived had lived just 18,000 years ago at a time when all archaic hominins were believed to be long extinct. Estimated to have been around thirty years old at the time of her death, ‘Flo’ stood just 1.06 m (3 ft. 6 in.) tall, weighed 16 and 36 kg (35 and 79 lb), and had an estimated cranial capacity of just 380 cc, comparable to that of an australopithecine.
Rapidly dubbed the ‘hobbit people’ on the grounds of their diminutive stature, the hominins were recognised as a new human species, Homo floresiensis. It was suggested that in the absence of natural enemies on an island where food is fairly scarce, ‘Flo’s’ people had undergone a process known as insular dwarfism, where smaller individuals are positively selected for and over several generations, the entire population ‘downsizes’.
Not everybody accepted this explanation. In 2006, the late Teuku Jacob claimed that Flo was a modern human of Australomelanesian extraction, who had suffered from a developmental disorder leading to a smaller brain known as microcephaly. Jacob found little support for his views and was also criticised for allegedly damaging the specimens while they were on loan to him from the Indonesian National Archaeological Research Center.
The controversy had been revived by the publication of two companion papers in the journal PNAS. Two of the authors of these new papers were also involved with Jacob’s original study. The first paper, Henneberg, et al (2014), argues that Flo was suffering from Down syndrome. This can result in atavism, where developmental characteristics of an earlier ancestral condition appear alongside undisrupted characteristics. This pattern could explain what has been otherwise interpreted as a mosaic of primitive and derived features. As a teratological specimen, the authors note that LB1 is not eligible to be designated the type specimen of a new species.
In the second paper, Eckhardt, et al (2014) suggest that based on an examination of the Flores specimens made in 2005, both the stature and brain size of LB1 have been underestimated. LB1, they argue, possessed abnormalities such as craniofacial asymmetry and a thigh bone disproportionately short in relation to its other long bones. Such abnormalities are indicative of Down syndrome and a number of other developmental conditions.
References:
1. Jacob, T. et al., Pygmoid Australomelanesian Homo sapiens skeletal remains from Liang Bua, Flores: Population affinities and pathological abnormalities. PNAS 103 (36), 13421–13426 (2006).
2. Henneberg, M., Eckhardt, R., Chavanaves, S. & Hsüc, K., Evolved developmental homeostasis disturbed in LB1 from Flores, Indonesia, denotes Down syndrome and not diagnostic traits of the invalid species Homo floresiensis. PNAS (Early Edition) (2014).
3. Eckhardt, R., Henneberg, M., Weller, A. & Hsüc, K., Rare events in earth history include the LB1 human skeleton from Flores, Indonesia, as a developmental singularity, not a unique taxon. PNAS (Early Edition) (2014).
Links (all papers are open access):
Jacob, et al http://www.pnas.org/content/103/36/13421.short
Henneberg, et al http://www.pnas.org/content/early/2014/07/31/1407382111.abstract
Eckhardt, et al http://www.pnas.org/content/early/2014/07/31/1407385111.abstract
The announcement in 2003 that dwarf hominins had been discovered at Liang Bua Cave on the Indonesian island of Flores was one of the major news stories of that year. The type specimen, LB1, a female inevitably dubbed ‘Flo’ had lived had lived just 18,000 years ago at a time when all archaic hominins were believed to be long extinct. Estimated to have been around thirty years old at the time of her death, ‘Flo’ stood just 1.06 m (3 ft. 6 in.) tall, weighed 16 and 36 kg (35 and 79 lb), and had an estimated cranial capacity of just 380 cc, comparable to that of an australopithecine.
Rapidly dubbed the ‘hobbit people’ on the grounds of their diminutive stature, the hominins were recognised as a new human species, Homo floresiensis. It was suggested that in the absence of natural enemies on an island where food is fairly scarce, ‘Flo’s’ people had undergone a process known as insular dwarfism, where smaller individuals are positively selected for and over several generations, the entire population ‘downsizes’.
Not everybody accepted this explanation. In 2006, the late Teuku Jacob claimed that Flo was a modern human of Australomelanesian extraction, who had suffered from a developmental disorder leading to a smaller brain known as microcephaly. Jacob found little support for his views and was also criticised for allegedly damaging the specimens while they were on loan to him from the Indonesian National Archaeological Research Center.
The controversy had been revived by the publication of two companion papers in the journal PNAS. Two of the authors of these new papers were also involved with Jacob’s original study. The first paper, Henneberg, et al (2014), argues that Flo was suffering from Down syndrome. This can result in atavism, where developmental characteristics of an earlier ancestral condition appear alongside undisrupted characteristics. This pattern could explain what has been otherwise interpreted as a mosaic of primitive and derived features. As a teratological specimen, the authors note that LB1 is not eligible to be designated the type specimen of a new species.
In the second paper, Eckhardt, et al (2014) suggest that based on an examination of the Flores specimens made in 2005, both the stature and brain size of LB1 have been underestimated. LB1, they argue, possessed abnormalities such as craniofacial asymmetry and a thigh bone disproportionately short in relation to its other long bones. Such abnormalities are indicative of Down syndrome and a number of other developmental conditions.
References:
1. Jacob, T. et al., Pygmoid Australomelanesian Homo sapiens skeletal remains from Liang Bua, Flores: Population affinities and pathological abnormalities. PNAS 103 (36), 13421–13426 (2006).
2. Henneberg, M., Eckhardt, R., Chavanaves, S. & Hsüc, K., Evolved developmental homeostasis disturbed in LB1 from Flores, Indonesia, denotes Down syndrome and not diagnostic traits of the invalid species Homo floresiensis. PNAS (Early Edition) (2014).
3. Eckhardt, R., Henneberg, M., Weller, A. & Hsüc, K., Rare events in earth history include the LB1 human skeleton from Flores, Indonesia, as a developmental singularity, not a unique taxon. PNAS (Early Edition) (2014).
Links (all papers are open access):
Jacob, et al http://www.pnas.org/content/103/36/13421.short
Henneberg, et al http://www.pnas.org/content/early/2014/07/31/1407382111.abstract
Eckhardt, et al http://www.pnas.org/content/early/2014/07/31/1407385111.abstract
Monday, 4 August 2014
Craniofacial changes after 80,000 years ago may reflect increased social tolerance
Did technology boom result from reduced male aggression?
An ambitious study published in the journal Current Anthropology has proposed a link between craniofacial changes and technological advances occurring after around 80,000 years ago. The authors suggest that a reduction in browridge projection and a shortening of the upper facial skeleton (referred to by the authors as ‘feminization’) was the result of either reduced testosterone levels or reduced androgen receptor densities. This reduced male aggression and increased social tolerance, in turn enabling larger groups to live together and the building of long-distance social networks. The consequence was that between around 80,000 and 30,000 years ago, there was acceleration of cumulative technological evolution or ‘cultural ratcheting’ where innovations accumulate over time as a result of cooperation between individuals and groups.
Robert Cieri and his colleagues considered over 1,400 skulls from prehistoric people living before and after 80,000 years ago, and from recent foragers and farmers. They found that a trend towards browridge reduction and facial shortening is apparent from after 80,000 years ago, consistent with the hypothesised higher testosterone levels or androgen receptor densities prior to that time.
The study is the latest attempt to resolve an apparent lag in the archaeological record between the appearance of anatomically modern humans and clear evidence for modern human behaviour in the form of symbolic expression, innovation and planning depth. Such evidence does not become apparent until after 80,000 years ago, leading some anthropologists to postulate a ‘smartness mutation’ occurring at about that time that somehow ‘rewired’ the human brain and enabled it function far more efficiently.
In the last fifteen years or so, the trend has been to look for demographic rather than cognitive explanations. The African Middle Stone Age has examples of seemingly precocious technological traditions such as Stillbay and Howieson’s Poort that were relatively short-lived and were replaced by more conservative traditions. It is argued that periodically, population levels fell to below the level needed to preserve the complex technological traditions from one generation to the next. It has also been suggested that evidence for symbolic behaviour in the form of beads and ornaments is indicative of more complex societies rather than more complex brains. Both fit well with the idea of more tolerant societies emerging after 80,000 years ago.
However, the most recent archaeological data has failed to correlate the disappearance of advanced technological traditions with demographic collapse, and indeed the extent to which such technologies were repeatedly lost has been questioned. For example, microliths are now known to have first appeared 165,000 years ago and their periodic disappearance from the archaeological record may be apparent rather than actual.
References:
1. Cieri, R., Churchill, S., Franciscus, R., Tan, J. & Hare, B., Craniofacial Feminization, Social Tolerance, and the Origins of Behavioral Modernity. Current Anthropology 55 (4), 419-443 (2014).
An ambitious study published in the journal Current Anthropology has proposed a link between craniofacial changes and technological advances occurring after around 80,000 years ago. The authors suggest that a reduction in browridge projection and a shortening of the upper facial skeleton (referred to by the authors as ‘feminization’) was the result of either reduced testosterone levels or reduced androgen receptor densities. This reduced male aggression and increased social tolerance, in turn enabling larger groups to live together and the building of long-distance social networks. The consequence was that between around 80,000 and 30,000 years ago, there was acceleration of cumulative technological evolution or ‘cultural ratcheting’ where innovations accumulate over time as a result of cooperation between individuals and groups.
Robert Cieri and his colleagues considered over 1,400 skulls from prehistoric people living before and after 80,000 years ago, and from recent foragers and farmers. They found that a trend towards browridge reduction and facial shortening is apparent from after 80,000 years ago, consistent with the hypothesised higher testosterone levels or androgen receptor densities prior to that time.
The study is the latest attempt to resolve an apparent lag in the archaeological record between the appearance of anatomically modern humans and clear evidence for modern human behaviour in the form of symbolic expression, innovation and planning depth. Such evidence does not become apparent until after 80,000 years ago, leading some anthropologists to postulate a ‘smartness mutation’ occurring at about that time that somehow ‘rewired’ the human brain and enabled it function far more efficiently.
In the last fifteen years or so, the trend has been to look for demographic rather than cognitive explanations. The African Middle Stone Age has examples of seemingly precocious technological traditions such as Stillbay and Howieson’s Poort that were relatively short-lived and were replaced by more conservative traditions. It is argued that periodically, population levels fell to below the level needed to preserve the complex technological traditions from one generation to the next. It has also been suggested that evidence for symbolic behaviour in the form of beads and ornaments is indicative of more complex societies rather than more complex brains. Both fit well with the idea of more tolerant societies emerging after 80,000 years ago.
However, the most recent archaeological data has failed to correlate the disappearance of advanced technological traditions with demographic collapse, and indeed the extent to which such technologies were repeatedly lost has been questioned. For example, microliths are now known to have first appeared 165,000 years ago and their periodic disappearance from the archaeological record may be apparent rather than actual.
References:
1. Cieri, R., Churchill, S., Franciscus, R., Tan, J. & Hare, B., Craniofacial Feminization, Social Tolerance, and the Origins of Behavioral Modernity. Current Anthropology 55 (4), 419-443 (2014).
Thursday, 31 July 2014
Evidence for Neolithic dairy farming in Finland
Lipid residues from prehistoric sherds reveal transition around 2500 BC
It has long been debated whether Neolithic farming economies were ever established at the limits of modern agriculture around the 60th parallel north. Thanks to the warming effects of the Gulf Stream, sustainable farming economies were established slightly to the south, in Britain, southern Norway and Sweden. In Finland, however, agriculture is problematic even today due to lower temperatures and a snow cover for several months of the year.
Corded Ware was a pan-European phenomenon during the third millennium BC. Corded Ware reached Finland, but despite the firm association of this culture with pastoral farming elsewhere in Europe, there is no evidence for it in Finland. A problem for archaeologists is the poor survival rate of archaeological remains in the acidic soils of the region.
Fortunately, these same conditions favour the preservation of certain classes of ancient biomolecules such as lipids in the walls of ancient ceramic cooking vessels. Carbon isotope analysis can then be used to determine the origins of such organic residues.
In a new study published in Proceedings of the Royal Seciety B, researchers took advantage if the availability of abundant sherds representing prehistoric cooking vessels to investigate the economy of prehistoric hunter–fisher–foragers using so-called Comb Ware, and possible early farmers associated with Corded Ware, Final Neolithic Kiukainen Ware, and Early Metal Age people.
Seventy prehistoric sherds were investigated, from sites in southern and southwestern Finland; 19 yielded residues amenable to analysis. Residues recovered from Comb Ware dating from 3900 to 3300 BC were found to be associated exclusively with marine products suggesting specialised subsistence strategies and/or the storage of marine commodities for exchange. By contrast, residues recovered from Corded Ware dating to around 2500 BC display isotopic signatures suggesting fats of ruminants. While these could indicate either domestic cattle or wild elk or reindeer, around half the residues are from milk, suggesting the former possibility. Notably, these milk residues were found in drinking beakers rather than storage amphorae. Only one Corded Ware vessel was found to contain residues of a marine origin despite the proximity of the sites investigated to the coast.
Unlike the other two, Final Neolithic Kiukainen Ware sherds revealed a mixed-economy of marine and ruminant products. Possibly marine elements were reintroduced to the economy as a hedge against deteriorating climate. The Early Metal Age residues were exclusively of dairy origin, suggesting the intensification of agriculture despite the continued deterioration of the climate.
The sharp contrast between the marine products associated with Comb Wares and domesticated products associated with Corded Wares supports the view that Corded Ware pottery represents the successful introduction of farming into Finland and also places the origins of farming and milk consumption at this northerly latitude at 4,500 years ago.
References:
1. Cramp, L. et al., Neolithic dairy farming at the extreme of agriculture in northern Europe. Proceedings of the Royal Seciety B 281 (2014).
Link:
http://rspb.royalsocietypublishing.org/content/281/1791/20140819.full
It has long been debated whether Neolithic farming economies were ever established at the limits of modern agriculture around the 60th parallel north. Thanks to the warming effects of the Gulf Stream, sustainable farming economies were established slightly to the south, in Britain, southern Norway and Sweden. In Finland, however, agriculture is problematic even today due to lower temperatures and a snow cover for several months of the year.
Corded Ware was a pan-European phenomenon during the third millennium BC. Corded Ware reached Finland, but despite the firm association of this culture with pastoral farming elsewhere in Europe, there is no evidence for it in Finland. A problem for archaeologists is the poor survival rate of archaeological remains in the acidic soils of the region.
Fortunately, these same conditions favour the preservation of certain classes of ancient biomolecules such as lipids in the walls of ancient ceramic cooking vessels. Carbon isotope analysis can then be used to determine the origins of such organic residues.
In a new study published in Proceedings of the Royal Seciety B, researchers took advantage if the availability of abundant sherds representing prehistoric cooking vessels to investigate the economy of prehistoric hunter–fisher–foragers using so-called Comb Ware, and possible early farmers associated with Corded Ware, Final Neolithic Kiukainen Ware, and Early Metal Age people.
Seventy prehistoric sherds were investigated, from sites in southern and southwestern Finland; 19 yielded residues amenable to analysis. Residues recovered from Comb Ware dating from 3900 to 3300 BC were found to be associated exclusively with marine products suggesting specialised subsistence strategies and/or the storage of marine commodities for exchange. By contrast, residues recovered from Corded Ware dating to around 2500 BC display isotopic signatures suggesting fats of ruminants. While these could indicate either domestic cattle or wild elk or reindeer, around half the residues are from milk, suggesting the former possibility. Notably, these milk residues were found in drinking beakers rather than storage amphorae. Only one Corded Ware vessel was found to contain residues of a marine origin despite the proximity of the sites investigated to the coast.
Unlike the other two, Final Neolithic Kiukainen Ware sherds revealed a mixed-economy of marine and ruminant products. Possibly marine elements were reintroduced to the economy as a hedge against deteriorating climate. The Early Metal Age residues were exclusively of dairy origin, suggesting the intensification of agriculture despite the continued deterioration of the climate.
The sharp contrast between the marine products associated with Comb Wares and domesticated products associated with Corded Wares supports the view that Corded Ware pottery represents the successful introduction of farming into Finland and also places the origins of farming and milk consumption at this northerly latitude at 4,500 years ago.
References:
1. Cramp, L. et al., Neolithic dairy farming at the extreme of agriculture in northern Europe. Proceedings of the Royal Seciety B 281 (2014).
Link:
http://rspb.royalsocietypublishing.org/content/281/1791/20140819.full
Friday, 11 July 2014
Chimpanzee gestures decoded
Study
may throw light on origins of human language
The use of gestures by chimpanzees
was first demonstrated by field studies carried out in the 1960s and 1970s, and
work on captive animals has shown that these gestures are part of an
intentional, goal-orientated behaviour common to all the great apes. While this
behaviour overlaps with human language, it is absent from most animal
communication systems and evidence for it is also lacking for the vocalisations
of great apes.
There has been considerable
interest in a potential common origin of great ape gestures and components of
human language and, therefore, in the actual meaning of the gestures.
Surprisingly, little work has been carried out in this area. In a new report,
published in the journal Current Biology,
researchers Catherine Hobaiter and Richard Byrne from the School of Psychology
& Neuroscience, University of St Andrews, have presented the first systematic
study of meaning in wild chimpanzee gestural communication. They have found
that individual gestures have specific meanings, independently of who is making
them, as is the case with words in human language. They have also provided a
partial ‘lexicon’.
The field studies were conducted in
the Budongo Forest in Uganda, and more than 80 chimpanzees were observed. The researchers
recorded the interactions of the chimpanzees and analysed 4,531 instances of
gestural communications between the animals, noting the motions they used and
how other chimpanzees responded. Some 36 gestures were analysed, and some 15
different meanings were identified.
Some of the gestures are unambiguous:
for example ‘leaf-clipping’ is only used to signal sexual attraction.
However,
many are associated with up to three meanings: for example, ‘grab’ is used for ‘stop
that’, ‘’climb on me’, and ‘move away’. This ambiguity may be apparent rather
than real, and may arise in part from the difficulty for human observers in
discerning subtle variations in the nature of the gesture. It is evident to a
human recipient whether or not a gentle touch is intended to make them move or
stay where they are, but such distinctions are very difficult to perceive visually.
Gestures were also employed towards two or three very similar outcomes: for example, ‘push’ is used for both ‘move
away’ and ‘stop that’.
Researchers found considerable
variation in whether an intended meaning was signalled by a single gesture type
or several gestures of apparently equivalent meaning. This was particularly
common in social negotiations, where a degree of persuasion was required. By contrast,
meanings typically conveyed by a single gesture were often well defined: for
example ‘initiate grooming’ is signalled by a big loud scratch.
References:
x
1. Hobaiter, C. & Byrne, R.,
The Meanings of Chimpanzee Gestures. Current Biology 24, 1-5
(2014).
x
Friday, 27 June 2014
Neanderthals ate their greens
Analysis
of 60,000 – 45,000 year old coprolites provides insight into Neanderthal diet
Neanderthal dietary reconstructions
have, to date, been based on archaeological evidence, stable isotope data and
studies of dental calculus. These suggest that they were predominantly meat
eaters, although plant foods made a contribution to their diet. Hitherto, there
has been no direct evidence for an omnivorous diet.
A new study, published in the open
access journal PLoS One has presented direct evidence of Neanderthal diet using
faecal biomarkers, which are a valuable analytical tool for identifying diet.
Researchers applied gas chromatography and mass spectroscopy techniques to coprolites
(fossil faeces) from the Neanderthal site of El Salt at Alicante, Spain. The coprolites
were recovered from sediments gathered from a number of levels at the site, which
was repeatedly occupied by Neanderthals between 60,000 and 45,000 years ago.
The team focussed on chemical
processes associated with the action of bacteria in the gut. They found a high
proportion of coprostanol, which the gut bacteria produce from cholesterol and
which is associated with the consumption of meat. However, they also recorded
significant quantities of 5β-stigmastanol, which is associated with plant
consumption.
Further tests were necessary to
confirm that the coprolites were of human origin. The conversion of cholesterol
into coprostanol is not unique to humans, but related molecules were also
identified in proportions that ruled out other omnivores.
References:
x
1. Ainara Sistiaga, A., Mallol,
C., Galván, B. & Everett Summons, R., The Neanderthal Meal: A New
Perspective Using Faecal Biomarkers. PLoS One 9 (6), e101045
(2014).
x
Link:
Friday, 20 June 2014
Sima de los Huesos hominins are proto-Neanderthals
New
study supports ‘accretion’ model
A new study, published in the
journal Science, has provided support
for the ‘accretion’ model of Neanderthal evolution. ‘Classic’ Neanderthals,
i.e. humans possessing the full suite of Neanderthal characteristics, do not
appear in the fossil record until 130,000 years ago. However, French palaeoanthropologist
Jean-Jacques Hublin has proposed that Neanderthal characteristics appeared
gradually over time, in a piecemeal fashion.
Thus, for example if Feature X
appeared in one population and Feature Y in another, then interbreeding between
the two populations would have resulted in a population possessing both Features
X and Y. Over time, populations gradually acquired the full suite of
Neanderthal characteristics by a process of accretion, resulting in a gradual
transition from Homo heidelbergensis to
Neanderthal. The accretion model explains ‘proto-Neanderthal’ features seen on
certain fossils dating to the period prior to the appearance of the ‘classic’
Neanderthals. These include a 400,000-year-old fragmentary skull from Swanscombe
in England and the 225,000-year-old Steinheim skull from Stuttgart, Germany.
Much of the evidence we have
regarding Neanderthal origins comes from a single site in the Sierra de
Atapuerca of northern Spain, near the city of Burgos: a Middle Pleistocene
human burial pit known as Sima de los Huesos. The name translates – rather
appropriately – as ‘the Pit of Bones’. Sima de los Huesos is a small muddy
chamber lying at the bottom of a 13 m (43 ft.) chimney, lying deep within the Cueva
Mayor system of caves. Investigation of the site has proved to be long and
difficult. The most immediate problems are logistical. The cramped site is
located more than 500 m (⅓
mile) from the mouth of the Cueva Mayor and is hard to access, necessitating at
times crawling on the stomach. Another problem is the disturbance to the site
caused by the many generations of souvenir and fossil hunters. Systematic
excavation commenced in 1984 and has continued ever since. To date, over 2,000
fragmentary hominin fossils have been recovered, including three skulls. In
total, the remains are thought to represent at least 32 individuals of both
sexes. It is likely that the site was simply used for the hygienic disposal of
the dead, because there is no evidence to suppose that any of the individuals
were deliberately killed and the bones show no sign of injuries caused by
spears or clubs.
Study of this enormous collection
of bones is still in progress, and is likely to continue for some time yet as
the site yields further fossils. However, it has become clear that the fossils
show a mixture of Homo heidelbergensis and
Neanderthal characteristics, just as would be expected if the accretion model
is correct. The key question is how old is the site? Uranium series dates
obtained in 2007 suggested that they were at least 530,000 years old, making
the Sima people older than some Homo
heidelbergensis remains from southern Europe and the Balkan region that show
no incipient Neanderthal characteristic features.
The new study considered 17 crania,
including seven new specimens. The sample shows a consistent morphological
pattern with derived Neanderthal features present in the face and anterior of
the cranial vault, many of which are adaptations to aid chewing of food. This
suggests that facial modification was the first step in the evolution of the
Neanderthal lineage, consistent with the accretion model evolution, with
different anatomical features evolving at different rates.
The researchers also used a variety
of techniques including combined electron spin resonance/uranium series to
obtain a revised date of 430,000 years old, which gives a far better fit with
the accretion model.
References:
x
1. Arsuaga, J. et al.,
Neandertal roots: Cranial and chronological evidence from Sima de los Huesos. Science
344 (6190), 1358-1363 (2014).
x
Sunday, 15 June 2014
Interbreeding between Neanderthals and modern humans
What
we know now
Whether or not modern humans interbred with Neanderthals is a question that has long been of interest to both scholars and lay people alike, but it was not until May 2010 that strong evidence emerged that the answer to the question was ‘yes, probably’.
A project to sequence the Neanderthal genome was commenced in 2006 at the Max Planck Institute for Evolutionary Anthropology (Green, et al., 2006; Green, et al., 2008), and in May 2010, researchers published a first draft of the Neanderthal genome (Green, et al., 2010). With the initial announcement came the dramatic news that made headlines around the world. It turned out that between one and four percent of the genome of modern non-Africans was derived from Neanderthals. In other words, the answer to the million dollar question was ‘yes, they did interbreed – but not in Africa’. The researchers compared the Neanderthal genome with those of five present-day individuals: two indigenous Africans (one San from South Africa and one Yoruba from West Africa) and three Eurasians (one from Papua New Guinea, one from China and one from France). The results showed that Neanderthals were more closely related to non-Africans than to Africans. This is not particularly surprising, as Neanderthals are not known to have lived in Africa. Any interbreeding has generally been supposed to have occurred within the known range of the Neanderthals, in Europe and western Asia. What was unexpected was that no difference was found between Papua New Guinean, Chinese and European individuals in terms of their degree of relatedness to Neanderthals.
The implication is that the interbreeding must have occurred before the ancestors of the present-day Asian, Australasian and European populations diverged from one another – presumably in Southwest Asia soon after modern humans first left Africa, and long before they reached Europe. If the population that left Africa was small, only limited interbreeding would be necessary to leave the Neanderthal contribution fixed in the modern non-African genome for all time, as numbers increased during the subsequent peopling of the world.
Interbreeding was not the only way to interpret these initial results, and the authors of the report said that they could not rule out the possibility that their results reflected substructure in the early modern human populations. In fact, a later independent study favoured this possibility, using a mathematical model to represent a connected string of regional populations spanning Africa and Eurasia. After the string split, the Eurasian and African parts of the range subsequently evolved into Neanderthals and modern humans respectively. For the latter, groups geographically closest to the split (i.e. in North Africa) remained more closely related to Neanderthals than those further south. It was assumed that the non-African world was subsequently populated by a dispersal of one of these northerly groups from Africa (Eriksson & Manica, 2012).
Subsequent work by independent researchers ruled out this substructure scenario (Sankararaman, et al., 2012; Yang, et al., 2012), and appeared to back the view that there had been a single episode of interbreeding very early on in the Out of Africa expansion that led to the peopling of the non-African world (Yotova, et al., 2011). The findings that some Africans do after all carry a Neanderthal genetic signature (Sánchez-Quinto, et al., 2012; Wall, et al., 2013) is not a major problem, as this can be accounted for in terms of a pre-Neolithic ‘Back to Africa’ migration of modern humans from Southwest Asia (Olivieri, et al., 2006; González, et al., 2007; Hodgson, et al., 2014).
A complication is that studies have found no trace of a Neanderthal component in mitochondrial DNA (Caramelli, et al., 2003; Serre, et al., 2004; Caramelli, et al., 2008). On the ‘brief encounter’ picture, this could mean crossbred women were sterile, and thus their mitochondrial DNA was never passed to subsequent generations. Another possibility is that interbreeding between Neanderthals and modern humans was very rare, with only one such event every couple of centuries. The reason could be limited biological compatibility, or it could be that the two mostly avoided interspecific mating. Such a low rate of interbreeding would account for the absence of Neanderthal mitochondrial DNA from the present-day gene pool, but it would still be sufficient to account for the observed levels of Neanderthal DNA in the nuclear genome. However, it would require interbreeding to occur across the whole of the Neanderthal range, not just in Southwest Asia (Currat & Excoffier, 2011; Neves & Serva, 2012).
Between 2012 and 2014, further studies showed that the original conclusion that all non-African populations were related equally to Neanderthals was incorrect, and that the proportion of Neanderthal ancestry in East Asians is 20 to 40 percent higher than it is in Europeans. This implies that interbreeding could not all have happened at a single time and place; some of it must have happened after the ancestral East Asian and European populations separated (Meyer, et al., 2012; Wall, et al., 2013; Vernot & Akey, 2014). Given that Neanderthals lived in Europe but are not known from East Asia, this is unexpected. However, their known range extents to the Altai region north of the Himalayas and a subsequent episode of interbreeding might have occurred there. Alternatively, it is possible that the Neanderthal range actually extended further south, as we know to have been the case for the Denisovans.
The latest work suggests that around 20 percent of the Neanderthal genome survives in the present-day population, albeit individuals each only possess a small fraction of this amount (Vernot & Akey, 2014).
Many useful Neanderthal genes have been incorporated into the modern genome; for example those involved with the production of keratin, a protein that is used in skin, hair and nails. Possibly the Neanderthal versions of these genes were more suited to the harsh conditions of Ice Age Europe (Sankararaman, et al., 2014). In East Asian populations, many genes involved with protection from UV are of Neanderthal origin (Ding, et al., 2014).
Some deleterious genes also have a Neanderthal connection, including those implicated in Type 2 diabetes and Crohn’s disease. Significantly, Neanderthal DNA was largely absent from the X chromosome and genes associated with modern testes. The implication is that Neanderthal DNA in these regions led to reduced male fertility, or sterility (Sankararaman, et al., 2014), consistent with the view that Neanderthals and modern humans were at the limits of biological compatibility.
These results show that natural selection had a significant role, with both positive and negative selection determining Neanderthal gene frequencies. It is entirely possible that selective factors could be at least partially responsible for the higher incidence of Neanderthal DNA in East Asian populations.
It is now clear that the interactions between Neanderthal and modern populations were complex; and that we are still at a very early stage of understanding them.
References:
1. Green,
R. et al., Analysis of one million base pairs of Neanderthal DNA. Nature 444,
330-336 (2006).
2. Green,
R. et al., A Complete Neandertal Mitochondrial Genome Sequence Determined by
High-Throughput Sequencing. Cell 134, 416–426 (2008).
3. Green,
R. et al., A Draft Sequence of the Neandertal Genome. Science 328, 710-722
(2010).
4. Eriksson,
A. & Manica, A., Effect of ancient population structure on the degree of
polymorphism shared between modern human populations and ancient hominins. PNAS
109 (35), 13956–13960 (2012).
5. Sankararaman,
S., Patterson, N., Li, H., Pääbo, S. & Reich, D., The Date of Interbreeding
between Neandertals and Modern Humans. PLoS Genetics 8 (10) (2012).
6. Yang,
M., Malaspinas, A., Durand, E. & Slatkin, M., Ancient Structure in Africa
Unlikely to Explain Neanderthal and Non-African Genetic Similarity. Molecular
Biology and Evolution 29 (10), 2987–2995 (2012).
7. Yotova,
V. et al., An X-Linked Haplotype of Neandertal Origin Is Present Among All
Non-African Populations. Molecular Biology and Evolution 28 (7), 1957-1962
(2011).
8. Sánchez-Quinto,
F. et al., North African Populations Carry the Signature of Admixture with
Neandertals. PLoS One 7 (10) (2012).
9. Wall,
J. et al., Higher levels of Neanderthal ancestry in East Asians than in
Europeans. Genetics 194, 199-209 (2013).
10. Olivieri,
A. et al., The mtDNA Legacy of the Levantine Early Upper Palaeolithic in
Africa. Science 314, 1757-1770 (2006).
11. González,
A. et al., Mitochondrial lineage M1 traces an early human backflow to Africa.
BMC Genomics 8 (223) (2007).
12. Hodgson,
J., Mulligan, C., Al-Meeri, A. & Raaum, R., Early Back-to-Africa Migration
into the Horn of Africa. PLoS Genetics 10 (6), e1004393 (2014).
13. Caramelli,
D. et al., Evidence for a genetic discontinuity between Neandertals and
24,000-year-old anatomically modern Europeans. PNAS 100 (11), 6593–6597 (2003).
14. Serre,
D. et al., No Evidence of Neandertal mtDNA Contribution to Early Modern Humans.
PLoS Biology 2 (3), 0313-0317 (2004).
15. Caramelli,
D. et al., A 28,000 Years Old Cro-Magnon mtDNA Sequence Differs from All
Potentially Contaminating Modern Sequences. PLoS One 3 (7) (2008).
16. Currat,
M. & Excoffier, L., Strong reproductive isolation between humans and
Neanderthals inferred from observed patterns of introgression. PNAS 108 (37),
15129-15134 (2011).
17. Neves,
A. & Serva, M., Extremely Rare Interbreeding Events Can Explain Neanderthal
DNA in Living Humans. PLoS One 7 (10) (2012).
18. Meyer,
M. et al., A High-Coverage Genome Sequence from an Archaic Denisovan
Individual. Science 338, 222-226 (2012).
19. Vernot,
B. & Akey, J., Resurrecting Surviving Neandertal Lineages from Modern Human
Genomes. Science 343, 1017-1021 (2014).
20. Sankararaman,
S. et al., The genomic landscape of Neanderthal ancestry in present-day humans.
Nature 507, 354–357 (2014).
21. Ding,
Q., Hu, Y., Xu, S., Wang, J. & Jin, L., Neanderthal Introgression at
Chromosome 3p21.31 Was Under Positive Natural Selection in East Asians.
Molecular Biology and Evolution 31 (3), 683-695 (2014).
Monday, 9 June 2014
Neolithic was brought to Europe by maritime colonists
Ancient and modern mitochondrial DNA study links PPNB to modern populations of Cyprus and Crete
In recent years, ancient DNA has been obtained from Neolithic human remains, and this has provided a more reliable picture of the genetic impact of the European Neolithic than was possible with genetic studies of living populations. However, researchers have been hampered by the lack of data from the original farmers of Southwest Asia.
In a new study, published in the open access journal PLoS One Genetics, researchers report the successful extraction of mitochondrial DNA from fifteen out of 63 skeletons recovered from the Pre Pottery Neolithic B (PPNB) sites of Tell Halula, Tell Ramad and Dja’de El Mughara, dating from between 8700 to 6600 BC.
The genetic profiles were compared with data obtained from human remains associated with the LBK and Cardial/Epicardial European Neolithic cultures. The researchers also looked for possible signatures of the original Neolithic expansion in the gene pools of present-day Southwest Asian and southern European populations, and tried to infer possible routes of the expansion by comparison with the ancient samples. They were able to identify K and N-derived mitochondrial DNA haplogroups as potential markers of the Neolithic expansion, whose genetic signature would have reached both the Iberian coasts and the Central European plain.
They also observed genetic affinities between the PPNB samples and the modern populations of Cyprus and Crete. However, no such link was found to modern populations of western Anatolia, suggesting that the Neolithic was first introduced into Europe by maritime colonists.
References:
1. Fernández, E. et al., Ancient DNA Analysis of 8000 B.C. Near Eastern Farmers Supports an Early Neolithic Pioneer Maritime Colonization of Mainland Europe through Cyprus and the Aegean Islands. PLoS One Genetics 10 (6), e1004401 (2014).
Link:
http://www.plosgenetics.org/article/info%3Adoi%2F10.1371%2Fjournal.pgen.1004401
In recent years, ancient DNA has been obtained from Neolithic human remains, and this has provided a more reliable picture of the genetic impact of the European Neolithic than was possible with genetic studies of living populations. However, researchers have been hampered by the lack of data from the original farmers of Southwest Asia.
In a new study, published in the open access journal PLoS One Genetics, researchers report the successful extraction of mitochondrial DNA from fifteen out of 63 skeletons recovered from the Pre Pottery Neolithic B (PPNB) sites of Tell Halula, Tell Ramad and Dja’de El Mughara, dating from between 8700 to 6600 BC.
The genetic profiles were compared with data obtained from human remains associated with the LBK and Cardial/Epicardial European Neolithic cultures. The researchers also looked for possible signatures of the original Neolithic expansion in the gene pools of present-day Southwest Asian and southern European populations, and tried to infer possible routes of the expansion by comparison with the ancient samples. They were able to identify K and N-derived mitochondrial DNA haplogroups as potential markers of the Neolithic expansion, whose genetic signature would have reached both the Iberian coasts and the Central European plain.
They also observed genetic affinities between the PPNB samples and the modern populations of Cyprus and Crete. However, no such link was found to modern populations of western Anatolia, suggesting that the Neolithic was first introduced into Europe by maritime colonists.
References:
1. Fernández, E. et al., Ancient DNA Analysis of 8000 B.C. Near Eastern Farmers Supports an Early Neolithic Pioneer Maritime Colonization of Mainland Europe through Cyprus and the Aegean Islands. PLoS One Genetics 10 (6), e1004401 (2014).
Link:
http://www.plosgenetics.org/article/info%3Adoi%2F10.1371%2Fjournal.pgen.1004401
Tuesday, 3 June 2014
KwaZulu-Natal findings refutes technological hiatus during African Middle Stone Age
Post-Howieson’s
Poort Sibudan tradition was not ‘unstructured and unsophisticated’
Archaeologists have long believed
that the later part of the African Middle Stone Age (MSA) was characterised by conservative
technologies punctuated by the appearance of technologically-sophisticated but
short-lived technocomplexes such as the Stillbay and Howieson’s Poort
traditions of South Africa. These traditions are noted for finely-worked stone
points, microliths, tools made from bone, and innovative technologies including
pressure flaking and compound adhesives. Various theories involving population
collapses have been put forward to account for their disappearance and the
reversion to comparatively unsophisticated prepared-core industries.
However, it has been suggested that
this phenomenon may be more apparent than real, as the Stillbay and Howieson’s
Poort eras have been studied far more closely than the supposed hiatus periods
that followed. Recent work at the archaeological site Sibudu, KwaZulu-Natal
supports the view. Archaeologists have identified a new technocomplex, which
they have named the Sibudan, from the six uppermost lithic assemblages at the
site. The new technocomplex dates from around 58,000 years ago, placing its’
beginning just after the end of the Howieson’s Poort era.
While the Sibudan has technological
parallels with other contemporary MSA industries, it is typologically and technologically
distinct. The six stratified tool assemblages are linked by common features, which
identify them as a distinct tradition. Many of these features are considered to
be hallmarks of a sophisticated stone tool-making technology, including
characteristic tool assemblages with standardised forms and reduction cycles, and
the production of standardised blades with soft stone hammers. Overall, the
Sibudan refutes the notion that post-Howieson’s Poort stone-knapping technologies
were rudimentary or unsophisticated.
The report is published in the open
access journal PLoS One.
References:
x
1. Will, M. B. G. & Conard,
N., Characterizing the Late Pleistocene MSA Lithic Technology of Sibudu,
KwaZulu-Natal, South Africa. PLoS One 9 (5), e98359 (2014).
x
Link:
Thursday, 29 May 2014
Human evolution favoured brain over brawn
Metabolite
study demonstrates human muscle and brain tissue underwent disproportionate
evolutionary change
A new study, published in the open
access journal PLoS One Biology, has used metabolites to track evolutionary
changes in brain and skeletal muscle tissues. Metabolites are metabolic products
or intermediated of low molecular weight (1,500 amu or less), which are
associated with the physiological processes that maintain the functionality of
body tissues. Changes in the concentrations of these metabolites are thought to
be closely related to evolutionary changes in the associated tissues.
Researchers measured the concentrations
of more than 10,000 metabolites in the prefrontal cortex, primary visual
cortex, cerebellar cortex, skeletal muscles and kidneys of humans, chimpanzees,
macaque monkeys and mice using mass spectrometry-based techniques. They found
that in most cases the differences reflected genetic distances between the
species rather than environmental differences.
The striking exception was found in
the human lineage. The concentration profiles of metabolites associated with the
human prefrontal cortex, cerebellar cortex and skeletal tissues showed far
greater changes than could be accounted for by genetic difference: by a factor
of four for the brain tissue, and eight for the muscle tissue. In fact the
muscle tissue is implied to have undergone more evolutionary change in the 6 to
7 million years since the divergence from chimpanzees than it did during the
130 or so million years separating mice from the common ancestor of the apes
and Old World monkeys. No comparable differences were noted for the primary
visual cortex or kidneys. Nor were significant differences to any of these
results found after controlling for differences in diet and levels of physical
activity.
It is well known that humans are
physically quite weak in comparison to chimpanzees, despite weighing in at
around twice the size. Surprisingly, this is largely based on anecdotal
observations mostly predating the 1950s. Accordingly, the researchers set macaque,
chimpanzee and human subjects a ‘pulling task’, which tested both upper and
lower body strength. These tests confirmed the anecdotal observations.
The researchers concluded that the
metabolic changes in human muscle tissue were associated with a drastic
reduction in muscle strength; and that these changes might be linked to the
changes in brain metabolism and enhanced cognitive abilities.
The findings are an extension of
Aiello and Wheeler’s ‘expensive tissue’ hypothesis, which proposed that the
considerable energy requirements of the human brain (around 20 percent of the
total energy budget) could only be met by making savings elsewhere. Aiello and
Wheeler (1995) proposed these savings were made by downsizing other
energetically-expensive organs, principally the gut. Apparently, though, this
was insufficient and further savings were required in the form of a decrease in
the energy expenditure of skeletal muscle.
References:
x
1. Bozek, K. et al.,
Exceptional Evolutionary Divergence of Human Muscle and Brain Metabolomes
Parallels Human Cognitive and Physical Uniqueness. PLoS One Biology 12
(5), e1001871 (2014).
2. Aiello, L. & Wheeler, P.,
The expensive tissue hypothesis: the brain and the digestive system in human
and primate evolution. Current Anthropology 36, 199-221 (1995).
x
Link (open access):
Sunday, 25 May 2014
The Venus of Willendorf
The Venus of Willendorf is a small 11.1 cm (4 3/8 in) high figurine carved from oolitic limestone and tinted with red ochre.
The 25,000-year-old figurine dates to the Gravettian period and is one of the most iconic artefacts of the European Upper Palaeolithic. It was discovered in 1908 by archaeologist Josef Szombathy near the village of Willendorf in Austria, and since then it has resided in the Naturhistorisches Museum, Vienna. It is currently on display in the Mineralogy galleries, having been relocated there while the Prehistory galleries undergo refurbishment. I took the photographs of the front, side and rear views when I visited the museum during a recent trip to Vienna. From a personal point of view, the enigmatic figurine did much to spark my interest in prehistory, so I was very keen to see it in person for the first time.
With its large breasts, full figure and exaggerated sexual characteristics, the contrast between the Venus of Willendorf and the classical portrayal of the Roman goddess could not be greater. Yet there is nothing crude or primitive about its execution; it is immediately obvious that the figurine is as finely-worked as anything from classical times.
The face is concealed behind rows of plaited hair, which comprise seven concentric bands surrounding the head, with two more semi-circular bands below at the back of the neck. Another interpretation is that the figurine is wearing a woven fibre hat.
Female figurines with similar attributes are known dating to throughout the European Upper Palaeolithic, though most are from the Gravettian period. Despite its obvious inaccuracy, the term ‘Venus figurines’ has been used to describe them since the first examples were found in the nineteenth century. They are often interpreted as fertility figures or mother goddesses, although their real function remains unknown.
The 25,000-year-old figurine dates to the Gravettian period and is one of the most iconic artefacts of the European Upper Palaeolithic. It was discovered in 1908 by archaeologist Josef Szombathy near the village of Willendorf in Austria, and since then it has resided in the Naturhistorisches Museum, Vienna. It is currently on display in the Mineralogy galleries, having been relocated there while the Prehistory galleries undergo refurbishment. I took the photographs of the front, side and rear views when I visited the museum during a recent trip to Vienna. From a personal point of view, the enigmatic figurine did much to spark my interest in prehistory, so I was very keen to see it in person for the first time.
With its large breasts, full figure and exaggerated sexual characteristics, the contrast between the Venus of Willendorf and the classical portrayal of the Roman goddess could not be greater. Yet there is nothing crude or primitive about its execution; it is immediately obvious that the figurine is as finely-worked as anything from classical times.
The face is concealed behind rows of plaited hair, which comprise seven concentric bands surrounding the head, with two more semi-circular bands below at the back of the neck. Another interpretation is that the figurine is wearing a woven fibre hat.
Female figurines with similar attributes are known dating to throughout the European Upper Palaeolithic, though most are from the Gravettian period. Despite its obvious inaccuracy, the term ‘Venus figurines’ has been used to describe them since the first examples were found in the nineteenth century. They are often interpreted as fertility figures or mother goddesses, although their real function remains unknown.
Thursday, 15 May 2014
13,000 year old skull and mtDNA reinforces continuity between Paleoindians and Native Americans
Teenaged girl ‘Naia’ shared craniofacial features with earliest-known Americans, but genetic profile is common among today’s Native Americans
The first people to reach the New World arrived around 15,000 years ago, having migrated across the Beringia land bridge that then linked Siberia to Alaska. The Paleoindians, as they are known, possessed craniofacial features that differ markedly to those of present-day Native Americans. Their skulls were long and narrow, the face narrow and the forehead prominent. By contrast, present-day Native Americans are broad-faced, with rounder skulls. A facial reconstruction of Kennewick Man – an 8,400 year old skull found in the Columbia River, Kennewick, WA – is said to bear startling a resemblance to the actor Sir Patrick Steward.
It has therefore been suggested that there were two migrations to the New World, with the Paleoindians arriving first and later being replaced by the ancestors of the present-day Native Americans. However, others argue that the differences arose in situ, possibly as a result of changes in diet when the Paleoindians adopted agriculture during the period between 8,000 and 2,000 years ago. Another possibility is that the changes are simply the result of genetic drift.
The ‘two migrations’ theory has received a significant setback with the recovery of a near-complete human skeleton of a female aged 15 to 16 years from Hoyo Negro, a submerged collapsed chamber in the Sac Actun cave system in the Yucatan Peninsula, Mexico. The skeleton has been nicknamed ‘Naia’ (Greek for ‘water nymph’), and it has been dated to between 12,000 and 13,000 years old. Naia’s craniofacial features are typical of the Paleoindian morphology, but mitochondrial DNA extracted from a molar teeth has been identified as belonging to the haplogroup D1, which occurs only among present-day Native Americans. This is consistent with the view that there was continuity between Paleoindians and present-day Native Americans.
Researchers now intend to sequence Naia’s nuclear DNA, which they hope will shed further light on the origins of the first Americans.
References:
1. Chatters, J. et al., Late Pleistocene Human Skeleton and mtDNA Link Paleoamericans and Modern Native Americans. Science 344, 750-754 (2014).
The first people to reach the New World arrived around 15,000 years ago, having migrated across the Beringia land bridge that then linked Siberia to Alaska. The Paleoindians, as they are known, possessed craniofacial features that differ markedly to those of present-day Native Americans. Their skulls were long and narrow, the face narrow and the forehead prominent. By contrast, present-day Native Americans are broad-faced, with rounder skulls. A facial reconstruction of Kennewick Man – an 8,400 year old skull found in the Columbia River, Kennewick, WA – is said to bear startling a resemblance to the actor Sir Patrick Steward.
It has therefore been suggested that there were two migrations to the New World, with the Paleoindians arriving first and later being replaced by the ancestors of the present-day Native Americans. However, others argue that the differences arose in situ, possibly as a result of changes in diet when the Paleoindians adopted agriculture during the period between 8,000 and 2,000 years ago. Another possibility is that the changes are simply the result of genetic drift.
The ‘two migrations’ theory has received a significant setback with the recovery of a near-complete human skeleton of a female aged 15 to 16 years from Hoyo Negro, a submerged collapsed chamber in the Sac Actun cave system in the Yucatan Peninsula, Mexico. The skeleton has been nicknamed ‘Naia’ (Greek for ‘water nymph’), and it has been dated to between 12,000 and 13,000 years old. Naia’s craniofacial features are typical of the Paleoindian morphology, but mitochondrial DNA extracted from a molar teeth has been identified as belonging to the haplogroup D1, which occurs only among present-day Native Americans. This is consistent with the view that there was continuity between Paleoindians and present-day Native Americans.
Researchers now intend to sequence Naia’s nuclear DNA, which they hope will shed further light on the origins of the first Americans.
References:
1. Chatters, J. et al., Late Pleistocene Human Skeleton and mtDNA Link Paleoamericans and Modern Native Americans. Science 344, 750-754 (2014).
Labels:
Ancient DNA,
human migrations,
Native Americans,
Paleoindians
Friday, 9 May 2014
Rice versus wheat agriculture could explain cultural differences within China, claim researchers
Greater interdependency found in rice-growing regions
People living in the rice-growing regions of southern China are more interdependent, loyal, and nepotistic, and less likely to divorce than their counterparts in the wheat-growing regions north of the Yangtze, according to a study published in the journal Science.
Han Chinese students from various regions in the country underwent a series of tests, including the ‘triad task’, which shows subjects lists of three items, such as train, bus, and tracks. They then decide which two items should be paired together. Two of the items (trains and buses) can be paired because they belong to the same category (trains and buses are forms of transport), and two (trains and tracks) because they share a functional relationship (trains run on tracks). Participants from rice-growing regions were more likely to pair the train and the track, whereas those from wheat-growing regions tended to pair the train and the bus.
The so-called ‘rice theory’ is an extension of subsistence style theory, which argues that some forms of subsistence (such as farming) require more functional interdependence than other forms (such as herding). Over time, societies that have to cooperate intensely become more interdependent, whereas societies that do not have to depend on each other as much become more individualistic. Previous studies have tended to focus on farming versus herding rather than differences between types of farming.
The two major differences between farming rice and wheat are irrigation and labour. Rice paddies require the construction and maintenance of elaborate irrigation systems, in turn requiring cooperation between farmers – often at village level. Farmers also need to coordinate their use of water so as not to adversely affect the supplies of their neighbours. Overall, growing paddy rice is at least twice as labour intensive as wheat farming.
The rice theory predicts that a Unus pro omnibus, omnes pro uno mentality will apply to anybody living in a region where rice has been farmed for thousands of years, not just those directly involved with its production. This prediction was borne out by the study, as few if any of the participants had actually farmed rice or wheat for a living.
My feelings are that while this is an interesting study, one should always be cautious about cultural determinism.
References:
1. Talhelm, T. et al., Large-Scale Psychological Differences Within China Explained by Rice Versus Wheat Agriculture. Science 344, 603-608 (2014).
Link:
http://www.sciencemag.org/content/344/6184/603
People living in the rice-growing regions of southern China are more interdependent, loyal, and nepotistic, and less likely to divorce than their counterparts in the wheat-growing regions north of the Yangtze, according to a study published in the journal Science.
Han Chinese students from various regions in the country underwent a series of tests, including the ‘triad task’, which shows subjects lists of three items, such as train, bus, and tracks. They then decide which two items should be paired together. Two of the items (trains and buses) can be paired because they belong to the same category (trains and buses are forms of transport), and two (trains and tracks) because they share a functional relationship (trains run on tracks). Participants from rice-growing regions were more likely to pair the train and the track, whereas those from wheat-growing regions tended to pair the train and the bus.
The so-called ‘rice theory’ is an extension of subsistence style theory, which argues that some forms of subsistence (such as farming) require more functional interdependence than other forms (such as herding). Over time, societies that have to cooperate intensely become more interdependent, whereas societies that do not have to depend on each other as much become more individualistic. Previous studies have tended to focus on farming versus herding rather than differences between types of farming.
The two major differences between farming rice and wheat are irrigation and labour. Rice paddies require the construction and maintenance of elaborate irrigation systems, in turn requiring cooperation between farmers – often at village level. Farmers also need to coordinate their use of water so as not to adversely affect the supplies of their neighbours. Overall, growing paddy rice is at least twice as labour intensive as wheat farming.
The rice theory predicts that a Unus pro omnibus, omnes pro uno mentality will apply to anybody living in a region where rice has been farmed for thousands of years, not just those directly involved with its production. This prediction was borne out by the study, as few if any of the participants had actually farmed rice or wheat for a living.
My feelings are that while this is an interesting study, one should always be cautious about cultural determinism.
References:
1. Talhelm, T. et al., Large-Scale Psychological Differences Within China Explained by Rice Versus Wheat Agriculture. Science 344, 603-608 (2014).
Link:
http://www.sciencemag.org/content/344/6184/603
Labels:
agriculture,
cultural determinism,
psychology,
rice,
wheat
Thursday, 8 May 2014
Study traces origins of Neolithic in South Asia
Eastward dispersal from Southwest Asia was slower than that unto Europe
A new study, published in the open-access journal PLoS One, has considered the eastwards spread of agriculture from Southwest Asia. This has been less well studied than the westwards expansion into Anatolia and Europe.
Researchers conducted a statistical analysis of radiocarbon dates for 160 Neolithic sites in western and southern Asia. The locations of these sites suggest that the dispersal of farmers eastwards from the Zagros followed two routes: a northern route via northern Iran, southern Central Asia and Afghanistan, and a southern route via Fars through the interior of southern Iran.
Analysis of the radiocarbon dates indicated an eastwards expansion at an average speed of 0.65 km per year, rather slower than the 1 km per year documented for Europe. The authors of report considered this to be unsurprising. Firstly, the arid climate and complicated topography of the region are less favourable for agriculture. Because of this, the early Neolithic settlements in Iran were relatively small and widely separated. Secondly, the European expansion was aided by the Danube, the Rhine and the Mediterranean coastline, but there are no major rivers in Afghanistan or Iran that could play a similar role.
The authors were encouraged that the fairly simple ‘wave of advance’ model used captured the salient features of the data studied, but stressed the need for a more detailed analysis that would consider local environments and climatic conditions.
References:
1. Gangal, K., Sarson, G. & Shukurov, A., The Near-Eastern Roots of the Neolithic in South Asia. PLoS One 19 (5), e95714 (2014).
Link:
http://www.plosone.org/article/info%3Adoi%2F10.1371%2Fjournal.pone.0095714
A new study, published in the open-access journal PLoS One, has considered the eastwards spread of agriculture from Southwest Asia. This has been less well studied than the westwards expansion into Anatolia and Europe.
Researchers conducted a statistical analysis of radiocarbon dates for 160 Neolithic sites in western and southern Asia. The locations of these sites suggest that the dispersal of farmers eastwards from the Zagros followed two routes: a northern route via northern Iran, southern Central Asia and Afghanistan, and a southern route via Fars through the interior of southern Iran.
Analysis of the radiocarbon dates indicated an eastwards expansion at an average speed of 0.65 km per year, rather slower than the 1 km per year documented for Europe. The authors of report considered this to be unsurprising. Firstly, the arid climate and complicated topography of the region are less favourable for agriculture. Because of this, the early Neolithic settlements in Iran were relatively small and widely separated. Secondly, the European expansion was aided by the Danube, the Rhine and the Mediterranean coastline, but there are no major rivers in Afghanistan or Iran that could play a similar role.
The authors were encouraged that the fairly simple ‘wave of advance’ model used captured the salient features of the data studied, but stressed the need for a more detailed analysis that would consider local environments and climatic conditions.
References:
1. Gangal, K., Sarson, G. & Shukurov, A., The Near-Eastern Roots of the Neolithic in South Asia. PLoS One 19 (5), e95714 (2014).
Link:
http://www.plosone.org/article/info%3Adoi%2F10.1371%2Fjournal.pone.0095714
Wednesday, 7 May 2014
How to think like a Neandertal, by Thomas Wynn and Frederick Coolidge
Of all early humans, none have captured the public imagination to anywhere near the extent of the Neanderthals. Indeed, with the possible exception of the dinosaurs, no extinct species is so deeply rooted in our popular culture. The idea that tens of thousands of years ago, people very much like ourselves shared the planet with another human species is one that intrigues many, although the term ‘Neanderthal’ is all too often used in a pejorative sense, and there is a widespread perception of the Neanderthals as dimwits.
In this engaging and accessible book, which is nevertheless as rigorous as any textbook, anthropologist Thomas Wynn and psychologist Frederick Coolidge paint a very different picture of the Neanderthals and their way of life. Drawing on archaeological and fossil evidence, they go beyond reconstructing the Neanderthal world and attempt to deduce their underlying thought processes.
In the first chapter, we are given an introduction to the world of the Neanderthals. From the start, Wynn and Coolidge refer to the Neanderthals as ‘people’, which is entirely correct as they were every bit as human as we are. The name comes from Neander Tal (‘Neander Valley’) near Dusseldorf, where Neanderthal remains were first identified in the 1850s (it was originally spelled ‘Neander Thal’, hence the more commonly-used spelling, but it has always been pronounced ‘tal’ and not ‘thal’). We learn that the Neanderthals were short, stocky, powerfully-built folk, with chinless, protruding faces, pronounced browridges over their eyes, and long, broad noses. The braincase was long and low, rather than the globular shape of modern people. Many features of their distinctive anatomy were adaptations to the harsh conditions of Ice Age Europe, but in comparison to very early humans it turns out that modern people are actually far more distinctive than Neanderthals.
An important difference is the shape of the braincase, which reflects the actual shape of the brain itself. Neanderthal brains were differently shaped to ours, and about ten percent larger. Does this mean that they were ten percent smarter than us? Wynn and Coolidge believe that they were neither more nor less intelligent than us – just different. This conclusion provides a focus for the rest of the book.
Neanderthals lived hard and died hard. Shanidar 1 lived in Iraq about 50,000 years ago, and was in his late 30s when he was killed by a rock fall. But long before his death he had suffered a number of major injuries, any one of which could have killed him. He owed his survival to caring companions, who nursed him back to health – and a dogged ability to cope with pain and life-changing injuries. Nor was Shanidar 1 particularly unusual: the pattern of healed injuries suffered by Neanderthals is very similar to those suffered by rodeo riders, suggesting that were regularly pitted against large, dangerous animals.
Each subsequent chapter focusses on a different aspect of Neanderthal life, and uses the evidence to build on this initial picture of them as tough but compassionate folk. Topics include hunting, spear making, family life, burial traditions and language. Wynn and Coolidge even examine Neanderthal humour before characterising them as pragmatic, stoical, risk-taking, empathic (in that they cared for their sick and injured), hard-hearted (in that they were prepared to leave the sick and injured behind if they needed to move camp), conservative (from the point of their extremely static technology, not their voting intentions), and xenophobic (in that they rarely met strangers and distrusted them when they did).
The final chapter plays a game of ‘Trading Places’ and speculates how a Neanderthal might fare in our modern world, and how a modern human in theirs. Wynn and Coolidge suggest that Neanderthals would do well in our world, and would excel as doctors, mechanics or soldiers. On the other hand, they suggest that a modern human would struggle to make a go of Neanderthal living.
The demise of the Neanderthals is covered fairly briefly. The arrival of modern humans in Ice Age Europe is viewed from the Neanderthal perspective. It is surmised that the end came when the climate began to deteriorate 30,000 years ago. This had happened before, and the Neanderthals had able to cope – but now they had competition. The modern humans were more adaptable and inventive when it came to finding new sources of food and developing new hunting methods. The Neanderthals retreated south to the Iberian Peninsula, where they held out for a while, but in the end they died out.
Wynn and Coolidge suggest that the Neanderthals may survive as dim cultural memories. Possibly some European folk traditions have their origins in ancient encounters with Neanderthals. More plausibly, they also suggest that our enduring fascination with the Neanderthals is that they were humans who led very different lives to ourselves, yet were still somehow like us. The Neanderthals live on as “inexact mirrors of ourselves”, Wynn and Coolidge conclude.
How to think like a Neandertal, by Thomas Wynn and Frederick Coolidge is published in the USA by Oxford University Press © 2012
In this engaging and accessible book, which is nevertheless as rigorous as any textbook, anthropologist Thomas Wynn and psychologist Frederick Coolidge paint a very different picture of the Neanderthals and their way of life. Drawing on archaeological and fossil evidence, they go beyond reconstructing the Neanderthal world and attempt to deduce their underlying thought processes.
In the first chapter, we are given an introduction to the world of the Neanderthals. From the start, Wynn and Coolidge refer to the Neanderthals as ‘people’, which is entirely correct as they were every bit as human as we are. The name comes from Neander Tal (‘Neander Valley’) near Dusseldorf, where Neanderthal remains were first identified in the 1850s (it was originally spelled ‘Neander Thal’, hence the more commonly-used spelling, but it has always been pronounced ‘tal’ and not ‘thal’). We learn that the Neanderthals were short, stocky, powerfully-built folk, with chinless, protruding faces, pronounced browridges over their eyes, and long, broad noses. The braincase was long and low, rather than the globular shape of modern people. Many features of their distinctive anatomy were adaptations to the harsh conditions of Ice Age Europe, but in comparison to very early humans it turns out that modern people are actually far more distinctive than Neanderthals.
An important difference is the shape of the braincase, which reflects the actual shape of the brain itself. Neanderthal brains were differently shaped to ours, and about ten percent larger. Does this mean that they were ten percent smarter than us? Wynn and Coolidge believe that they were neither more nor less intelligent than us – just different. This conclusion provides a focus for the rest of the book.
Neanderthals lived hard and died hard. Shanidar 1 lived in Iraq about 50,000 years ago, and was in his late 30s when he was killed by a rock fall. But long before his death he had suffered a number of major injuries, any one of which could have killed him. He owed his survival to caring companions, who nursed him back to health – and a dogged ability to cope with pain and life-changing injuries. Nor was Shanidar 1 particularly unusual: the pattern of healed injuries suffered by Neanderthals is very similar to those suffered by rodeo riders, suggesting that were regularly pitted against large, dangerous animals.
Each subsequent chapter focusses on a different aspect of Neanderthal life, and uses the evidence to build on this initial picture of them as tough but compassionate folk. Topics include hunting, spear making, family life, burial traditions and language. Wynn and Coolidge even examine Neanderthal humour before characterising them as pragmatic, stoical, risk-taking, empathic (in that they cared for their sick and injured), hard-hearted (in that they were prepared to leave the sick and injured behind if they needed to move camp), conservative (from the point of their extremely static technology, not their voting intentions), and xenophobic (in that they rarely met strangers and distrusted them when they did).
The final chapter plays a game of ‘Trading Places’ and speculates how a Neanderthal might fare in our modern world, and how a modern human in theirs. Wynn and Coolidge suggest that Neanderthals would do well in our world, and would excel as doctors, mechanics or soldiers. On the other hand, they suggest that a modern human would struggle to make a go of Neanderthal living.
The demise of the Neanderthals is covered fairly briefly. The arrival of modern humans in Ice Age Europe is viewed from the Neanderthal perspective. It is surmised that the end came when the climate began to deteriorate 30,000 years ago. This had happened before, and the Neanderthals had able to cope – but now they had competition. The modern humans were more adaptable and inventive when it came to finding new sources of food and developing new hunting methods. The Neanderthals retreated south to the Iberian Peninsula, where they held out for a while, but in the end they died out.
Wynn and Coolidge suggest that the Neanderthals may survive as dim cultural memories. Possibly some European folk traditions have their origins in ancient encounters with Neanderthals. More plausibly, they also suggest that our enduring fascination with the Neanderthals is that they were humans who led very different lives to ourselves, yet were still somehow like us. The Neanderthals live on as “inexact mirrors of ourselves”, Wynn and Coolidge conclude.
How to think like a Neandertal, by Thomas Wynn and Frederick Coolidge is published in the USA by Oxford University Press © 2012
Tuesday, 6 May 2014
The engraved ochres of Blombos Cave
World’s earliest abstract art
Seventy-three thousand years ago, an elderly man sat in the mouth of a limestone cave, intently working on a small rectangular piece of reddish-brown ochre. From time to time, he paused in his work and stared out towards the sea that lay a kilometre away. First he scraped and ground the piece flat on two sides and then, with the aid of a sharp stone tool, he engraved a cross-hatched geometrical design upon one of the newly-ground facets. It was the second such piece he had made, but there would be no others because a few weeks later he fell ill with a respiratory disease. A younger man would probably have recovered, but at 48 he was old and worn out. Within a few days, he was dead.
When his companions eventually decided it was time to move on from the cave that had been their home for the last six months, they took most of their few possessions with them. But the old man’s ochres were forgotten and left behind. Within a few months, the ochres and all other traces of the brief occupation were buried beneath wind-blown sand, and they would not see the light of day again for very long time indeed….
In actuality, we have no idea who engraved the two pieces of ochre found at Blombos Cave in 2002, and although it is likely that they were both the work of the same individual we cannot be certain. The cave is located on the southern coast of South Africa in a limestone cliff 35 m (115 ft.) above sea level, 100 m (330 ft.) from the coast, though when occupied the coastline was further away. Discovered by archaeologist Christopher Henshilwood, it is one of the most extensively researched sites from the African Middle Stone Age.
Henshilwood has been familiar with the site since his childhood, since it is located on land owned by his grandfather. As a boy, he found a number of artefacts, dating from comparatively recent prehistoric times. In 1991, he returned there as a PhD student, hoping to discover similar artefacts. Instead, he found a number of bone tools and stone points that dated from a far earlier period, over 70,000 years ago.
After completing his PhD at the University of Cambridge, Henshilwood obtained funding to commence excavations at Blombos Cave, and he continues to lead work at the site to this day. Three Middle Stone Age phases of occupation have been identified. These are known as M1 (73,000 years ago), M2 (subdivided between an upper phase 77,000 years ago and a lower phase 80,000 years ago) and M3 (125,000 years ago). Each phase contains a number of occupation layers, but they are quite shallow indicating that the cave was only occupied sporadically and for relatively short periods of time.
However, while the cave was in use its occupants enjoyed a varied diet of large fish, shellfish, seals, dolphins and land mammals. Mole rats were often roasted over a fire and eaten; these large burrowing rodents are considered a delicacy by local farm workers to this day. The later occupations of the cave are associated with the Stillbay tool industry, which has first identified in the 1920s and named for the village of Still Bay, which lies a short distance from Blombos Cave.
The Stillbay was one of the cutting-edge industries of the African Middle Stone Age, and was noted for its finely-worked leaf-shaped stone points, which were made from high-quality materials including chert, quartzite and silcrete. The Stillbay people also made and used bone awls and projectile points, similar to those seen in ethnographic collections. Such implements are far more difficult to manufacture than stone tools. Other examples of Stillbay high tech included compound adhesives for hafting stone points to spears, and the use of heat treatment and pressure flaking for finishing stone artefacts. The Stillbay industry was widespread, and not confined to the region around Blombos Cave and Still Bay. Curiously, however, it was short-lived and persisted for less than a thousand years, before being replaced by seemingly less advanced industries of the type more typical of the African Middle Stone Age.
Perhaps the most important discovery at Blombos Cave has been the engraved ochres. Ochres are a range of minerals containing iron oxide that exist in a range of colours including red, yellow, brown and purple. They have long been used as pigments and their first known use was at least 266,000 years ago at Twin Rivers, a complex of caves in southern Zambia – before the appearance of modern humans. It is possible that the Twin Rivers ochre was used for utilitarian purposes, such as for making adhesives, for medicinal purposes, hide processing, or even as Stone Age sunblock. However, the consistent selection of brightly-coloured and often hard to grind materials suggests an ornamental explanation such as for body painting. In South Africa, red ochre appears in the archaeological record from at least 160,000 years ago, and invariably material with the reddest hues seems to have been preferred – again suggesting a non-utilitarian purpose.
Several thousand pieces of ochre have been found at Blombos Cave, and in 2002, Henshilwood reported the two pieces of engraved ochre from the 73,000 year old M1 phase, which were catalogued as AA 8937 and AA 8938. Both had been engraved with cross-hatched patterns, using a sharp stone tool to make wide grooves upon surfaces previously prepared by grinding. On AA 8938, in addition to cross-hatching, the pattern is bounded top and bottom by parallel lines, with a third parallel line running through the middle. The fact that the two pieces are so similar suggests a deliberate intent, rather somebody absent-mindedly scratching away at the pieces with a sharp object. Somebody who knew just what they were doing must have sat down and engraved the two pieces. Other engraved ochres were later identified, although they were less spectacular than AA 8937 and AA 8938. They came from all three phases of the site, and some were over 100,000 years old.
The Blombos Cave ochres are central to the debate about the emergence of modern human behaviour, which anthropologists define as the ability of humans to use symbols to organise their thoughts and actions. Symbols are anything that refers to an object or an idea, and can take the form of sounds, images or objects. They may refer directly to an object or idea, for example a representational image; or they may be totally abstract, such as spoken or written words. Thus for example a drawing of a cat, the sound ‘cat’ or the written letters ‘c-a-t’ may all be used to refer to a cat. We use symbols all the time – whenever we read a newspaper, check the time, consult a map or admire a painting or sculpture. All of these activities involve symbolic behaviour: human society could not function without it. Modern syntactical language is a system of communication that uses symbols in the form of spoken and (in the last six thousand years) written words to enable an effectively infinite range of meanings to be conveyed.
The earliest human species such as Homo habilis and Homo erectus are thought to have had only a very limited ability to use symbols, but it is hotly debated when the fully symbolic behaviour of present-day people emerged. Was it shared with some archaic humans – in particular the Neanderthals – or was it limited to Homo sapiens, emerging at the same time as anatomical modernity around 200,000 years ago? Some go further and argue that even Homo sapiens lacked behavioural modernity until about 40,000 to 50,000 years ago. Proponents of this view believe that a behavioural ‘Great Leap Forward’ occurred at this time as a result of a favourable genetic mutation that rewired the brain and enabled syntactical language and other trappings of behavioural modernity to develop.
They base this view around the observation that artefacts that are unequivocally the products of modern thought processes – cave paintings, figurines and carvings – do not appear in the archaeological record until that time. But Henshilwood argues that the engraved geometrical patterns on the ochres imply the existence of modern syntactical language, and that modern human behaviour must therefore have emerged much earlier.
Henshilwood dismisses other possible explanations for the marks on the ochres. For example, he claims that they could not the by-product of testing for the quality of powder that could be obtained from the ochres, as only a few lines would be required for this purpose. He also believes that the marks are unlikely to have been the result of absent-minded doodling because great care was taken in completing the patterns and ensuring the incisions matched up. Furthermore, engraving lines on hard pieces of ochre requires full concentration in order to apply the right pressure and keep the depth of incision constant. He believes that not only were the marks on the ochres made with deliberate intent, but recurring motifs on ochres found in all three of the Middle Stone Age phases are evidence of a tradition of engraved geometric patterns that began more than 100,000 years ago and persisted for tens of millennia.
The most obvious question is what was the significance of the geometric patterns? Henshilwood notes that the Christian cross would appear equally abstract to somebody unfamiliar with religious iconography. It is possible that the patterns meant something quite specific to the people who made them, though just what we simply don’t know and probably never will know.
Another question is if humans were able to produce abstract art over 100,000 years ago, why was figurative art not seen until so much later? One possibility is that humans were still not behaviourally fully modern and were not at this stage able to make figurative images, though Henshilwood rejects this possibility. He notes that there are many cultures that do not make figurative art, and many others that do so using perishable materials that would not survive for tens of thousands of years.
Henshilwood believes the fact that the ochre engravings were intentionally created and depict distinctive geometrical patterns is enough to demonstrate that they are the product of a society of behaviourally-modern humans. Given the evidence for technological sophistication during the Stillbay period, we should not find this unduly surprising.
Photo credit:
Image copyright held by author, Chris Henshilwood
Photo by Henning (2007)
Webpage available at: http://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:BBC-artefacts.jpg
Licence: CC by Share Alike 3.0 unported
Seventy-three thousand years ago, an elderly man sat in the mouth of a limestone cave, intently working on a small rectangular piece of reddish-brown ochre. From time to time, he paused in his work and stared out towards the sea that lay a kilometre away. First he scraped and ground the piece flat on two sides and then, with the aid of a sharp stone tool, he engraved a cross-hatched geometrical design upon one of the newly-ground facets. It was the second such piece he had made, but there would be no others because a few weeks later he fell ill with a respiratory disease. A younger man would probably have recovered, but at 48 he was old and worn out. Within a few days, he was dead.
When his companions eventually decided it was time to move on from the cave that had been their home for the last six months, they took most of their few possessions with them. But the old man’s ochres were forgotten and left behind. Within a few months, the ochres and all other traces of the brief occupation were buried beneath wind-blown sand, and they would not see the light of day again for very long time indeed….
In actuality, we have no idea who engraved the two pieces of ochre found at Blombos Cave in 2002, and although it is likely that they were both the work of the same individual we cannot be certain. The cave is located on the southern coast of South Africa in a limestone cliff 35 m (115 ft.) above sea level, 100 m (330 ft.) from the coast, though when occupied the coastline was further away. Discovered by archaeologist Christopher Henshilwood, it is one of the most extensively researched sites from the African Middle Stone Age.
Henshilwood has been familiar with the site since his childhood, since it is located on land owned by his grandfather. As a boy, he found a number of artefacts, dating from comparatively recent prehistoric times. In 1991, he returned there as a PhD student, hoping to discover similar artefacts. Instead, he found a number of bone tools and stone points that dated from a far earlier period, over 70,000 years ago.
After completing his PhD at the University of Cambridge, Henshilwood obtained funding to commence excavations at Blombos Cave, and he continues to lead work at the site to this day. Three Middle Stone Age phases of occupation have been identified. These are known as M1 (73,000 years ago), M2 (subdivided between an upper phase 77,000 years ago and a lower phase 80,000 years ago) and M3 (125,000 years ago). Each phase contains a number of occupation layers, but they are quite shallow indicating that the cave was only occupied sporadically and for relatively short periods of time.
However, while the cave was in use its occupants enjoyed a varied diet of large fish, shellfish, seals, dolphins and land mammals. Mole rats were often roasted over a fire and eaten; these large burrowing rodents are considered a delicacy by local farm workers to this day. The later occupations of the cave are associated with the Stillbay tool industry, which has first identified in the 1920s and named for the village of Still Bay, which lies a short distance from Blombos Cave.
The Stillbay was one of the cutting-edge industries of the African Middle Stone Age, and was noted for its finely-worked leaf-shaped stone points, which were made from high-quality materials including chert, quartzite and silcrete. The Stillbay people also made and used bone awls and projectile points, similar to those seen in ethnographic collections. Such implements are far more difficult to manufacture than stone tools. Other examples of Stillbay high tech included compound adhesives for hafting stone points to spears, and the use of heat treatment and pressure flaking for finishing stone artefacts. The Stillbay industry was widespread, and not confined to the region around Blombos Cave and Still Bay. Curiously, however, it was short-lived and persisted for less than a thousand years, before being replaced by seemingly less advanced industries of the type more typical of the African Middle Stone Age.
Perhaps the most important discovery at Blombos Cave has been the engraved ochres. Ochres are a range of minerals containing iron oxide that exist in a range of colours including red, yellow, brown and purple. They have long been used as pigments and their first known use was at least 266,000 years ago at Twin Rivers, a complex of caves in southern Zambia – before the appearance of modern humans. It is possible that the Twin Rivers ochre was used for utilitarian purposes, such as for making adhesives, for medicinal purposes, hide processing, or even as Stone Age sunblock. However, the consistent selection of brightly-coloured and often hard to grind materials suggests an ornamental explanation such as for body painting. In South Africa, red ochre appears in the archaeological record from at least 160,000 years ago, and invariably material with the reddest hues seems to have been preferred – again suggesting a non-utilitarian purpose.
Several thousand pieces of ochre have been found at Blombos Cave, and in 2002, Henshilwood reported the two pieces of engraved ochre from the 73,000 year old M1 phase, which were catalogued as AA 8937 and AA 8938. Both had been engraved with cross-hatched patterns, using a sharp stone tool to make wide grooves upon surfaces previously prepared by grinding. On AA 8938, in addition to cross-hatching, the pattern is bounded top and bottom by parallel lines, with a third parallel line running through the middle. The fact that the two pieces are so similar suggests a deliberate intent, rather somebody absent-mindedly scratching away at the pieces with a sharp object. Somebody who knew just what they were doing must have sat down and engraved the two pieces. Other engraved ochres were later identified, although they were less spectacular than AA 8937 and AA 8938. They came from all three phases of the site, and some were over 100,000 years old.
The Blombos Cave ochres are central to the debate about the emergence of modern human behaviour, which anthropologists define as the ability of humans to use symbols to organise their thoughts and actions. Symbols are anything that refers to an object or an idea, and can take the form of sounds, images or objects. They may refer directly to an object or idea, for example a representational image; or they may be totally abstract, such as spoken or written words. Thus for example a drawing of a cat, the sound ‘cat’ or the written letters ‘c-a-t’ may all be used to refer to a cat. We use symbols all the time – whenever we read a newspaper, check the time, consult a map or admire a painting or sculpture. All of these activities involve symbolic behaviour: human society could not function without it. Modern syntactical language is a system of communication that uses symbols in the form of spoken and (in the last six thousand years) written words to enable an effectively infinite range of meanings to be conveyed.
The earliest human species such as Homo habilis and Homo erectus are thought to have had only a very limited ability to use symbols, but it is hotly debated when the fully symbolic behaviour of present-day people emerged. Was it shared with some archaic humans – in particular the Neanderthals – or was it limited to Homo sapiens, emerging at the same time as anatomical modernity around 200,000 years ago? Some go further and argue that even Homo sapiens lacked behavioural modernity until about 40,000 to 50,000 years ago. Proponents of this view believe that a behavioural ‘Great Leap Forward’ occurred at this time as a result of a favourable genetic mutation that rewired the brain and enabled syntactical language and other trappings of behavioural modernity to develop.
They base this view around the observation that artefacts that are unequivocally the products of modern thought processes – cave paintings, figurines and carvings – do not appear in the archaeological record until that time. But Henshilwood argues that the engraved geometrical patterns on the ochres imply the existence of modern syntactical language, and that modern human behaviour must therefore have emerged much earlier.
Henshilwood dismisses other possible explanations for the marks on the ochres. For example, he claims that they could not the by-product of testing for the quality of powder that could be obtained from the ochres, as only a few lines would be required for this purpose. He also believes that the marks are unlikely to have been the result of absent-minded doodling because great care was taken in completing the patterns and ensuring the incisions matched up. Furthermore, engraving lines on hard pieces of ochre requires full concentration in order to apply the right pressure and keep the depth of incision constant. He believes that not only were the marks on the ochres made with deliberate intent, but recurring motifs on ochres found in all three of the Middle Stone Age phases are evidence of a tradition of engraved geometric patterns that began more than 100,000 years ago and persisted for tens of millennia.
The most obvious question is what was the significance of the geometric patterns? Henshilwood notes that the Christian cross would appear equally abstract to somebody unfamiliar with religious iconography. It is possible that the patterns meant something quite specific to the people who made them, though just what we simply don’t know and probably never will know.
Another question is if humans were able to produce abstract art over 100,000 years ago, why was figurative art not seen until so much later? One possibility is that humans were still not behaviourally fully modern and were not at this stage able to make figurative images, though Henshilwood rejects this possibility. He notes that there are many cultures that do not make figurative art, and many others that do so using perishable materials that would not survive for tens of thousands of years.
Henshilwood believes the fact that the ochre engravings were intentionally created and depict distinctive geometrical patterns is enough to demonstrate that they are the product of a society of behaviourally-modern humans. Given the evidence for technological sophistication during the Stillbay period, we should not find this unduly surprising.
Photo credit:
Photo by Henning (2007)
Webpage available at: http://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:BBC-artefacts.jpg
Licence: CC by Share Alike 3.0 unported
Monday, 5 May 2014
Comment on Villa & Roebroeks (2014) ‘An Archaeological Analysis of the Modern Human Superiority Complex’.
A paper by Paola Villa and Wil Roebroeks ( 1) in the open access journal PLOS ONE has reviewed archaeological evidence for the view that the ‘inferiority’ of Neanderthals to modern humans was responsible for their demise. See this post for a quick summary.
Villa and Roebroeks are critical of view that comparisons between the archaeological records of the African Middle Stone Age and European Middle Palaeolithic can be used to demonstrate that Neanderthals were ‘inferior’ to modern humans in terms of a wide range of cognitive and technological abilities, and have made a very good case.
However, they seem to be dismissive of the impact of what they describe as ‘subtle biological differences’ between Neanderthals and modern humans, which they state ‘tend to be overinterpreted’. They cite Pearce, Stringer and Dunbar (2013) as an example.
Pearce, Stringer and Dunbar used eye socket size as a proxy for the size of the eye itself and showed that Neanderthals had larger eyes than modern humans. This is not an unexpected result; living at high latitudes, Neanderthals experienced lower light levels than people living in the tropics, and larger eyes might have been an evolutionary response. The consequence is that in comparison to a modern human brain, a greater proportion of the Neanderthal brain might have needed to be dedicated to the visual cortex, with the trade-off that less was available for other cognitive functions. Pearce, Stringer and Dunbar suggested that Neanderthals were less able than modern humans to maintain the complex social networks required to manage long-distance trade networks effectively, and learn about the existence of distant foraging areas unaffected by local shortages. Furthermore, their ability to develop and pass on innovations might have been limited in comparison to modern humans ( 2).
On a less subtle level, it is only to be expected that the neural organisation of the Neanderthal brain would have differed from that of modern humans. The globular brain case of Homo sapiens differs from the long, low braincase that characterised archaic human species, including Neanderthals, and the change reflects a change in the actual proportions of the brain. In comparison to archaic humans, the parietal lobes of modern humans are expanded, and these are associated with the processing of speech-related sounds ( 3, 4). It is possible that their development played a role in the development of syntactic language in Homo sapiens and that Neanderthals used different and partially non-verbal forms of communication ( 5).
While Villa and Roebroeks have demonstrated the risks of over-reliance on archaeological evidence, the biological differences between Neanderthals and modern humans are real. These differences must be included within a holistic approach to understanding the cognitive abilities of the Neanderthals, who as we now know are far from extinct in that they live on in the genome of modern populations.
References:
1. Villa, P. & Roebroeks, W., Neandertal Demise: An Archaeological Analysis of the Modern Human Superiority Complex. PLoS One 9 (4), e96424 (2014).
2. Pearce, E., Stringer, C. & Dunbar, R., New insights into differences in brain organization between Neanderthals and anatomically modern humans. Proceedings of the Royal Society B 280 (1758) (2013).
3. Wynn, T. & Coolidge, F., in Rethinking the human revolution, edited by Mellars, P., Boyle, K., Bar-Yosef, O. & Stringer, C. (McDonald Institute, Cambridge, 2007), pp. 79-90.
4. Coolidge, F. & Wynn, T., The Rise of Homo sapiens (Wiley-Blackwell, Hoboken, NJ, 2009).
5. Mithen, S., The Singing Neanderthal (Weidenfeld & Nicholson, London, 2005).
Villa and Roebroeks are critical of view that comparisons between the archaeological records of the African Middle Stone Age and European Middle Palaeolithic can be used to demonstrate that Neanderthals were ‘inferior’ to modern humans in terms of a wide range of cognitive and technological abilities, and have made a very good case.
However, they seem to be dismissive of the impact of what they describe as ‘subtle biological differences’ between Neanderthals and modern humans, which they state ‘tend to be overinterpreted’. They cite Pearce, Stringer and Dunbar (2013) as an example.
Pearce, Stringer and Dunbar used eye socket size as a proxy for the size of the eye itself and showed that Neanderthals had larger eyes than modern humans. This is not an unexpected result; living at high latitudes, Neanderthals experienced lower light levels than people living in the tropics, and larger eyes might have been an evolutionary response. The consequence is that in comparison to a modern human brain, a greater proportion of the Neanderthal brain might have needed to be dedicated to the visual cortex, with the trade-off that less was available for other cognitive functions. Pearce, Stringer and Dunbar suggested that Neanderthals were less able than modern humans to maintain the complex social networks required to manage long-distance trade networks effectively, and learn about the existence of distant foraging areas unaffected by local shortages. Furthermore, their ability to develop and pass on innovations might have been limited in comparison to modern humans ( 2).
On a less subtle level, it is only to be expected that the neural organisation of the Neanderthal brain would have differed from that of modern humans. The globular brain case of Homo sapiens differs from the long, low braincase that characterised archaic human species, including Neanderthals, and the change reflects a change in the actual proportions of the brain. In comparison to archaic humans, the parietal lobes of modern humans are expanded, and these are associated with the processing of speech-related sounds ( 3, 4). It is possible that their development played a role in the development of syntactic language in Homo sapiens and that Neanderthals used different and partially non-verbal forms of communication ( 5).
While Villa and Roebroeks have demonstrated the risks of over-reliance on archaeological evidence, the biological differences between Neanderthals and modern humans are real. These differences must be included within a holistic approach to understanding the cognitive abilities of the Neanderthals, who as we now know are far from extinct in that they live on in the genome of modern populations.
References:
1. Villa, P. & Roebroeks, W., Neandertal Demise: An Archaeological Analysis of the Modern Human Superiority Complex. PLoS One 9 (4), e96424 (2014).
2. Pearce, E., Stringer, C. & Dunbar, R., New insights into differences in brain organization between Neanderthals and anatomically modern humans. Proceedings of the Royal Society B 280 (1758) (2013).
3. Wynn, T. & Coolidge, F., in Rethinking the human revolution, edited by Mellars, P., Boyle, K., Bar-Yosef, O. & Stringer, C. (McDonald Institute, Cambridge, 2007), pp. 79-90.
4. Coolidge, F. & Wynn, T., The Rise of Homo sapiens (Wiley-Blackwell, Hoboken, NJ, 2009).
5. Mithen, S., The Singing Neanderthal (Weidenfeld & Nicholson, London, 2005).
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)

